How to Buy a Saxophone
by Ralph Bowen
The saxophone is perhaps the most widely heard solo instrument of the wind family in
popular and jazz music. It has a singing quality with a rich middle register, commanding
low register, and an exciting and colorful extended range. Young saxophonists can enjoy
performing in many large ensembles including concert, jazz, and marching bands as well as
wind ensemble. Although not a regular member of the orchestra woodwind section, orchestral
composers occasionally score for one or more saxophones, and sometimes incorporate a
saxophone quartet. There is also a good body of concerto repertoire for the saxophone.
The study of the saxophone inevitably involves learning soprano, alto, tenor and baritone.
Most players, however, choose to establish a recognizable solo voice on only one of these.
Additionally, saxophonists often double on clarinet and flute in order to open up more
opportunities for employment.
Invented in the 1840s by Adolphe Sax of Brussels, Belgium, the saxophone is the most recently
developed member of the woodwind family. It is a hybrid instrument with a key system based on
the Boehm fingering system c.1832, as is the case with the clarinet, oboe, and flute. The
saxophone has a conical bore like an oboe, a reed and mouthpiece like a clarinet, and a
metal body (brass) like the brass family of instruments.
THE SAXOPHONE FAMILY
1. Sopranino Eb
2. C Melody Soprano C
3. Soprano Bb
4. Alto Eb
5. C Melody C
6. Tenor Bb
7. Baritone Eb
8. Bass Bb
9. Contrabass Eb
10. Subcontrabass Bb
1, 3, 4, 6, 7, & 8 are most commonly used. 1 & 8 are used mainly in orchestral and wind ensemble works, less so in jazz and commercial music. 2 & 5 were used mostly in the earlier part of the 20th century for players who did not wish to transpose. Piano or violin parts could be read with greater ease, for instance.
Classical saxophonists include Marcel Mule, Guy Lacour, Daniel Duffayet, Eugene Rousseau, Donald Sinta, and Fred Hemke. James Houlik is one of the very few classical saxophonists whose specialty is the tenor saxophone.
In the jazz world, soprano saxophonists include Sidney Bechet, John Coltrane, Wayne Shorter, Jane Ira Bloom, and Sam Newsome. Alto saxophonists include Benny Carter, Johnny Hodges, Charlie Parker, Cannonball Adderly, Ornette Coleman, Anthony Braxton and David Sanborn. Tenor saxophonists include Lester Young, Stan Getz, John Coltrane, Sonny Rollins, Dave Liebman, and Michael Brecker. Lastly, baritone saxophonists include Harry Carney, Pepper Adams, Gary Smulyan, Gerry Mulligan, and Cecil Payne.
The saxophone quartet is a popular ensemble among both jazz and classical performers with a substantial collection of repertoire available. Quartets provide a wonderful learning experience for the developing saxophonist. Professional quartets include The World Saxophone Quartet, The Amherst Saxophone Quartet, The 29th Street Saxophone Quartet, and Prism.
IS THE SAXOPHONE DIFFICULT TO PLAY?
Unlike the flute and clarinet, the saxophone is very accommodating in the early stages of
musical development. Within the standard range, notes respond easily, even with the most
undeveloped embouchure _ the position of the lips in producing a tone _ and breathing
technique. The saxophone is not as prone to "squeak" like the clarinet or sound airy and
flat like the flute in the beginning. Soon thereafter, however, much attention need be
given to the development of good posture, support, relaxation, hand position, breathing,
embouchure, articulation, and manual dexterity. With all of these components functioning
independent of one another, it should come as no surprise that the saxophone demands a
great deal of concentration, as is the case with all musical instruments.
Beginners often have difficulty producing the low notes or "bell tones" and the high
notes or "palm keys." The extended range or "altissimo register" should not be explored
until the player has a firm grasp of proper breathing, embouchure, and tone production.
Essential to learning any instrument is development of the inner ear, or aural
perception of sound. Having a reference in one's inner ear as to what to strive for in
terms of tone and interpretation can be the most important motivation for any player.
Having an aural reference such as a CD recording or concert performance, like a picture,
is worth a thousand words. Daily adjustments made through trial and error in order to
improve embouchure, breathing and articulation are often motivated simply by a sound or
aural image in one's mind. It is therefore imperative that the developing player listen
to and watch as many masters of the saxophone as possible in order to make progress.
BUYING YOUR FIRST INSTRUMENT
The traditional starting place for the beginning saxophonist is with the alto
saxophone. This is in part due to the fact that that vast majority of classical
saxophone literature is written for the alto. Additionally, the alto requires
slightly less air than does the tenor, and the smaller key scale often fits more
comfortably in a young person's hands. Further, the angle of air flow as well as
the embouchure required to play alto is very much transferable to all of the saxophones.
These points do not, however, preclude a beginner from starting on tenor or baritone
saxophone. With proper guidance, repertoire and technique can be adapted to all of the
saxophones. Consult your local music store, school music teacher, or private teacher
for suggestions on which brands and models to try. See if your private teacher would
mind trying out a few instruments on your behalf. |
INTERMEDIATE, AND PROFESSIONAL
Generally, student horns play well, but lack features and craftsmanship of
professional instruments. As you move from a student horn to an intermediate
horn and then finally to a professional instrument, major differences will become apparent.
A great deal of effort has been taken by many manufacturers to produce student
instruments that are both affordable and musically satisfying to play. Most student
horns produce a pleasant tone with considerable ease and feel relatively comfortable
in the beginner's hands. In the case of a younger student, check to make sure that he
or she does not have difficulty closing keys, especially the "spatula" keys. A student
horn is a good way to go if you or your child's commitment is questionable. After three
or four years of good use, a move to a better instrument can be made, possibly facilitated
at least in part by a trade-in of your student horn.
As you can imagine, the intermediate horn is a little easier on the pocketbook, yet it
has some features that resemble a professional horn. The key work feels similar that of
a professional horn, yet it may not produce quite the same quality of tone. Intermediate
horns usually lack the hand work found on professional models.
Response, intonation, and tone quality are greatly improved with a professional instrument.
Great care is taken in designing the tube through experimentation with different metal
alloys, their weight and thickness. The design and placement of tone holes and posts is
given much consideration, using silver solder in many cases. Adjustment screws and
adjustable felt bumpers are also included on professional horns. Much more hand work
is done as is the case with hand-hammered keys and hand-engraving. Also, choices with
respect to finish become available. These include clear or colored lacquer, and silver
and gold plating. Professional horns in general, feel more comfortable and substantial
in one's hands. Finally, the resale value of a professional horn usually is quite
LACQUER VS. PLATING
The standard finish for a saxophone is clear lacquer, however, different colored lacquers
are now available. The color of the lacquer does not significantly affect the sound, but
plating can. Silver-plated instruments, purchased for the most part by military and
marching bands, produce a slightly brighter tone than lacquered horns. Gold-plated
horns have a warm, heavy sound and can cost considerably more.|
NEW VS. USED
A used saxophone is a viable option to purchasing a new instrument. For a similar
amount of money, a jump can be made from a new intermediate instrument to a used
professional instrument, for instance. Be sure to check the used instrument for
dents (recent and repaired)and re-soldering, as well as the condition of the pads.
The pads should feel soft and appear to fill up the key cup to its edges. Also, ask
if the horn has been re-lacquered. A re-lacquered horn is not necessarily a bad thing
if you are happy with it. It could, however, affect the resale value of the instrument
down the road. You might find used student horns at your local music store, perhaps an
instrument that was rented out for the school year. Often, both used instrument dealers
and local music stores offer a basic warranty with the purchase of a used instrument.
PICKING A MOUTHPIECE, LIGATURE, AND REED
Beginners should start on a hard rubber mouthpiece with a small tip opening and low
baffle. After deciding on a mouthpiece, try out some ligatures. Look for one that
holds the reed in place while not compressing it at the sides. A "reverse" ligature,
one with the screws on top is best. It is important to pick a good-quality reed,
since it is the reed which triggers the vibration of sound within the instrument.
Beginning students are, however, often careless with their reeds, so reed care
accessories are recommended. Teaching a beginner to simply put the mouthpiece
cap on will prevent destruction of the reed, not to mention the mouthpiece.
A sturdy neck strap or harness is a must. For reed care, a reed case, knife, trimmer,
and re-surfacer are most helpful. A mouthpiece pouch protects the mouthpiece while in
the case. A swab is good for keeping the tube clean. A music stand, method books, and
a good selection of CDs will get things started.
WHERE TO BUY
There are a few options available when purchasing a saxophone: your local music store,
a mail-order service, or private party selling a secondhand instrument. Each has its
benefits, but important things to consider are price, quality, and service. Improper
maintenance and accidents can lead to potential problems, such as damaging dents and
dings which can affect more than just the looks of the instrument. You may want to
choose a music store with a repair person on-site or, if you purchase from a mail-order
service, it would be wise to have a repair shop available to you locally.
Canadian-born saxophonist Ralph Bowen is a member of the jazz faculty at Rutgers University,
New Brunswick, N.J., where he is currently the coordinator of the jazz department, director
of the Jazz Ensemble, and professor of saxophone and music theory. He has performed or
recorded with Freddie Hubbard, Wynton Marsalis, Branford Marsalis, Dennis Chambers, Ron
Carter, Michel Camilo, Lou Rawls, Horace Silver and other leading artists. His album
Free Trade received the 1994 Juno Award for Best Canadian Jazz Album of the Year.